#Login Register
Rating System Update
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average


12-05-2014, 08:55 AM #11
tigur AC Guide
*
Status: Offline Posts:133 Threads:25 Joined:Apr 2014
From another thread:

(12-04-2014, 01:02 PM)holy Wrote:  [9:55:05 PM] PM to cyro : the last 2 games ive won in cta and my rank hasnt gone up any at all - unreal hosted the game
[9:55:15 PM] PM to cyro : hours ago now

1) There was a discussion on how a player noticed his rating continued to go lower after winning a CTA match.
2) This is about how ratings may not be working out and further research is needed.
3) Since it takes time and research for one player to show that a player's ratings will continue to decrease no matter the outcome of the CTAs, there may be an issue that may or may not be known.
This post was last modified: 12-05-2014, 08:56 AM by tigur.

12-06-2014, 08:22 AM #12
A MF S Still n00b
*
Status: Offline Posts:117 Threads:20 Joined:Mar 2014
More then likely chances are there were people on his team that had adjustments greater than him that probably knocked him down. Just a guess.

[Image: 235909-tradewars-2002.jpg]

12-06-2014, 12:37 PM #13
holy n00b
*
Status: Offline Posts:39 Threads:1 Joined:Nov 2014
(12-06-2014, 08:22 AM)A MF S Wrote:  More then likely chances are there were people on his team that had adjustments greater than him that probably knocked him down. Just a guess.

no, I can find the links to the games but I had the highest + on the team.

[Image: ik2a2mw.jpg]
"How fucking stupid and foolish of you to think you could do this"

12-06-2014, 07:43 PM #14
A MF S Still n00b
*
Status: Offline Posts:117 Threads:20 Joined:Mar 2014
(12-06-2014, 12:37 PM)holy Wrote:  
(12-06-2014, 08:22 AM)A MF S Wrote:  More then likely chances are there were people on his team that had adjustments greater than him that probably knocked him down. Just a guess.

no, I can find the links to the games but I had the highest + on the team.

I am not sure what "the highest +" means. Please clarify.

But, as odo said. If two players are on a team that are close in rating but, games played are drastically different the player with a low Games Played will have a bigger swing adjustment.

Two players are on a team, player A and B. A and B get the CTA win. Player A is at 1600 with 100 games played. Player B is at 1590 with only 25 games played. Player B will have a bigger adjustment which could put player A down a notch if that game meant more to player B on a rating scheme.

This seems to be the case as code does not change. In a rating system the numbers are pretty much all solid and so the equation can't have many faults.

I could be wrong on this. However, to argue against it means you took into account each and every players ratings, games played, and game wins/loses for each and every CTA you played in. This is also assuming you know the exact equation that is in the code.

Is this the case? I do not know because I do not know the players involved nor the code that determines such things.

[Image: 235909-tradewars-2002.jpg]

07-04-2015, 04:56 PM #15
Fordus Still n00b
*
Status: Offline Posts:170 Threads:27 Joined:Apr 2014
I believe the rating system needs to be looked at. http://cta.critical-hq.net/player.php?pl...e=Firesoul
See this link or attached screenshot.

In my last 15 games I've won all but 3. All 3 losses have only been by 1 cap. Some of the wins are substantial cap margins. Yet, my rating has dropped about 150 points in these games. I don't know if my account is just bugged, or it's like this for everyone, but something doesn't make sense in the way it's calculating things.


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
   

07-05-2015, 01:38 AM #16
Bone Still n00b
*
Status: Offline Posts:238 Threads:37 Joined:Apr 2014
From what I remember, your rating was 1600+ even in the 4v4 Competitive Go last night. So you've lost actually about 100 rating in the last 3 games alone. That's where the significant drop off occurred. You lost 2 and won 1. Still shouldn't be that large of a drop in rating though based off of that. There is one thing that stands out however when you look at those 3 games stats.

Whoever submitted the Stroked.1 game that you lost, has the winning team with 6 players listed. Your team (the losing team) only has 5 players. Maybe there was a sub? Maybe they left someone off your team? Either way, the rating system has one team with a much higher rating than the other team since it has one extra person, which is going to throw the results way out of sync. Not saying that's 100% the cause, but seems logical with your rating being fine prior to those last 2 CTA's you participated in.

07-05-2015, 12:08 PM #17
Fordus Still n00b
*
Status: Offline Posts:170 Threads:27 Joined:Apr 2014
Pretty sure I was about 1700 before the past 15 games. so it's actually like a 200 pt drop off, I saw after I posted this that my rating decreased even further.

Even before the past 3 games, my rating has been steadily declining, even though I went 11-1 in 12 games.

07-05-2015, 01:06 PM #18
bigdaddy n00b
*
Status: Offline Posts:29 Threads:3 Joined:Apr 2014
The system is broke, I win 63% of my games and lost 400 points
This post was last modified: 07-05-2015, 01:50 PM by bigdaddy.

07-06-2015, 02:58 AM #19
InSoMnIaC Still n00b
*
Status: Offline Posts:133 Threads:25 Joined:Apr 2014
-2 pts per day for not playing. smurfing wont affect rating unless you play around 10 games.






Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread:
1 Guest(s)